Modern legal systems and the principle of “Culpa in Contrahendo”: A review of the Albanian model of pre-contractual liability on a Roman-Germanic model reference.

Authors

  • Borana Mustafaraj Faculty of Law, University of Tirana Academic Counsellor at the School of Magistrates of Albania

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.7336/academicus.2019.19.06

Abstract

The doctrine of “culpa in contrahendo” constitutes an integral part of the legal systems of different states, although its content differs from one country to another. “Culpa in contrahendo”, as the states with a civil law system recognize, is bound by the obligation to act in good faith during the pre-contractual phase. It represents a responsibility that derives from the injurious behavior of the party during the stage of the contract. The common problem of various modern systems lies in classifying this responsibility, and the solution that states give is expanding the meaning of the contract or the meaning of non-contractual damage, since they do not categorize it as a sui generis responsibility. In Albanian law, there is no special provision for pre-contractual, however, the provision of Article 674 of the civil code may be considered as a basic provision that imposes liability at the negotiation stage. Regarding the nature of this responsibility, it is difficult to admit that it is of a contractual nature, when Albanian case law, despite the low number of cases, has considered it as extra contractual damage. Also, the European Court of Justice has foreseen pre-contractual liability as an extra contractual liability. The lack of unification regarding the rights, obligations and the way of protection against damage at the pre-contractual stage may cause uncertainty, especially in international trade relations.

Keywords:

culpa in contrahendo, pre-contractual liability, pre-contractual fault,

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

  1. Ben-Dror, Yoav. “The Perennial Ambiguity of Culpa in Contrahendo.” The American Journal of Legal History 27.2 (1983): 142-198.

  2. Çela, Ervis, and Maks Qoku. “Contractual Obligations under the Private International Law in Albania.” Academicus: International Scientific Journal 2014.10 (2014): 170-180.

  3. Dernburg, Arrigo. “Diritto delle obbligazioni.” (1903)., translated from german by Francesco Bernardino Cicala, Fratelli Bocca, Torino.

  4. Du Plessis, Paul J. Borkowski’s textbook on Roman Law. Oxford University Press, USA, 2015. UET Press, ISBN: 978-99956-39-10—5.

  5. Farnsworth, E. Allan. “Precontractual liability and preliminary agreements: fair dealing and failed negotiations.” Columbia Law Review 87.2 (1987): 217-294.

  6. Febbrajo, Tommaso. “Good Faith and Pre-Contractual Liability in Italy: Recent Developments in the Interpretation of Article 1337 of the Italian Civil Code.” Italian LJ 2 (2016): 291.

  7. Galgano, Francesco, Private Law, 1999.

  8. Kessler, Friedrich, and Edith Fine. “Culpa in contrahendo, bargaining in good faith, and freedom of contract: A comparative study.” Harvard Law Review (1964).

  9. Liçenji, Anjeza, and Kestrin Katro. “Albanian legal framework on Factoring contract.” Academicus: International Scientific Journal2013.8 (2013): 161-171.

  10. Markesinis, Basil S., Hannes Unberath, and Angus C. Johnston. The German Law of Contract: a comparative treatise. Bloomsbury Publishing, 2006.

  11. Law No. 7850, dated 29.07.1994, “Civil Code of the Republic of Albania”.

  12. Law No. 10428, dated 02.06.2011, “International private law”.

  13. Italian Civil Code.

  14. French Civil Code.

  15. German Civil Code.

  16. Case no. 70-14154, date 20.03.1972, of the Court of Cassation of France.

  17. Case no. 2425, date 27.10.1961, of the Supreme Court of Cassation of Italy.

  18. Case no. 20106, date 18.09.2009, of the Supreme Court of Cassation of Italy.

  19. Case nr. 963, datë 18.02.1986, of the Supreme Court of Cassation of Italy.

  20. Case no. 10249, date 16.10.1998 of the Supreme Court of Cassation of Italy.

  21. Case no. 14188, date 12.07.2016 of the Supreme Court of Cassation of Italy.

  22. Case no. 238, 00-2015-2446, date 07.05.2015, of the Supreme Court of Albania.

  23. Fonderie Officine Meccaniche Tacconi spa vs Heinrich Wagner Sinto Maschinenfabrik GmbH (HWS), C-334/00, European Court of Justice.

Downloads

Published

2019-01-01

How to Cite

Mustafaraj, B. (2019) “Modern legal systems and the principle of ‘Culpa in Contrahendo’: A review of the Albanian model of pre-contractual liability on a Roman-Germanic model reference”., Academicus International Scientific Journal. Vlora, Albania, 10(19), pp. 80–94. doi: 10.7336/academicus.2019.19.06.